Kelly Thompson Says Black Cloak and The Cull Nearly Drained Her, but Absolute Wonder Woman Might Change the Math

ComicsA writer's worktable at night beside a rain-streaked window, covered in comic thumbnail pages of faceless silhouettes, with a cup of black coffee and a glass jar of blank metal tokens beside a glowing green banker's lamp.

Kelly Thompson is one of the busiest writers in comics right now, but she says her last big creator-owned push nearly broke her. On David Harper’s Off Panel podcast, the Absolute Wonder Woman writer talked about the money behind Black Cloak and The Cull, and Bleeding Cool has transcribed some of her most candid comments.

“I don’t know how anyone makes independent comics on their own dime,” Thompson said. “We barely made it to do eleven issues of Black Cloak and five issues of The Cull plus a few other things here and there, little things. I could barely fund it with the Substack money.”

Both series began on Substack in 2021, Black Cloak with artist Meredith McClaren and The Cull with Mattia De Iulis, before moving to print at Image Comics, and both received Eisner nominations. But Thompson said the return did not match what it cost to make them. “I mean, there was no money left. I had to run back to work for hire,” she said. “All I really learned is that it’s really hard and that I’m sort of afraid to go back.”

She described the usual advice given to creators: do work-for-hire books to pay the rent, and treat creator-owned work as a kind of retirement plan that might pay off later if it gets optioned or collected again. She also said that outside of a “crazy weird hit,” many creators are not making good money, and that she has never fully understood why some books take off and others don’t.

Thompson is not ruling out a return. “I want to believe that sort of levelling up my profile with Absolute Wonder Woman and with Jeff and stuff maybe can make those numbers do different things, but I don’t know,” she said. “Nobody can show you a spreadsheet to tell you, hey, yeah, you’re going to do this much if you do this new creator-owned for a number one from you right now.” DC’s Absolute line has been one of the biggest success stories in comics, with titles like Absolute Catwoman recently extended to 12 issues.

For now, she is sticking with the safer path, and she would like to bring a familiar collaborator with her. “I’m trying to get Meredith to do some Absolute Wonder Woman, too,” she said.