The Only CGC 9.6 Action Comics #1 Sells for $976,000, Just Short of Its $1 Million Estimate

ComicsA vintage comic book in a clear graded plastic slab on a velvet auction podium under a spotlight, its cover blurred and unreadable.

The highest-graded copy of Superman’s first appearance has a new owner. The only Action Comics #1 ever graded CGC 9.6 sold for $976,000 at Landry Pop Auctions on Tuesday night, according to the auction house’s results. That is just short of the $1 million-plus estimate the house put on the book.

The copy is a restored one. It carries CGC’s purple label with an A-5 restoration score, which marks the work as excellent in quality but extensive in scope. The grader notes list color touch, added pieces, a sealed and reinforced spine split, cleaning, a lightened interior and replaced staples. Landry Pop said the restoration was done long before the book was recently certified, and that it is the only Action Comics #1 to earn a 9.6 on any label, with none graded higher.

The final price matches what the book was already bid to going into the sale. Speaking to The Comics Beat ahead of the auction, Landry Pop founder Travis Landry said bidding stood at $800,000 plus the buyer’s premium, and that “if it closes now, that buyer is paying 976,000.” He said 72 people had registered to bid and called the sale “totally uncharted territory.”

Even short of seven figures, the result is a big number for a restored copy. Landry said the highest price for a restored Action Comics #1 at auction before this one was $575,000. He also pointed to a reported $1.3 million private sale on the floor of New York Comic Con this year, though the details of that deal have not been made public.

Unrestored copies are in another league. ICv2 noted that an unrestored CGC 9.0 copy sold for $15 million earlier this year, and that only around 100 copies of the 1938 issue are believed to exist. Action Comics #1, created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, introduced Superman, Lois Lane and Zatara.

We covered the book when it headed to auction after being shown at New York Comic Con. Landry Pop followed the single-lot sale with a 145-lot auction of comics and original art on Wednesday.