Pikmin 4 Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy, a $10 upgrade that arrived Thursday, Nov. 12, 2026, had a 2.1 Metacritic user score from 265 ratings at the time Kotaku wrote about the backlash Monday, far below the original 2023 Switch game’s 8.9 user score.
The upgrade adds improved visuals, voice commands for the rescue dog Oatchi, and a new set of bonus stages in Dandori Academy. Owners of the original Switch version can pay $10 for it, Kotaku and Polygon both reported.
The user reviews Kotaku quoted keep circling the same complaints: the game still runs at 30 frames per second, load times are longer than on the original Switch, and the new Dandori Academy stages mostly reuse maps from the base game and can only be played at certain times. One Metacritic user, PrestonandTom, called it “essentially a paid downgrade,” writing that standard load times went from about 6 seconds to more than 30 seconds and that the frame rate went from a consistent 30 fps to an inconsistent 30 fps.
Even some of the harsher user reviews grant that the higher resolution is a plus, and Polygon notes that a few players like being able to give Oatchi voice commands. On the Pikmin subreddit, Kotaku and Polygon both found longtime fans who called the Metacritic reaction overdramatic and said the release is in line with some of Nintendo’s other Switch 2 Edition upgrades, or that new enemy placements make the reused Academy maps feel different.
Nintendo first offered a free demo of the Switch 2 Edition on Nov. 2, after Shigeru Miyamoto marked Nov. 1 as Pikmin Day, as we covered when that demo went live.
