London’s Competition Appeal Tribunal has dismissed a $2.6 billion UK class action that accused Sony of charging unfair PlayStation Store prices, rejecting a bid that had sought cheaper games and third-party stores on PlayStation.
In a judgment issued Tuesday, Nov. 17, the tribunal found that Alex Neill Class Representative Limited had failed to establish that Sony infringed competition law. The case, first reported by The Game Business, was brought on behalf of about 12.2 million UK consumers who bought digital PlayStation games or add-on content between Aug. 19, 2016, for customers in England and Wales, or Aug. 19, 2017, in Scotland, and Feb. 12, 2026.
The claim, filed in 2022 by consumer campaigner Alex Neill, alleged that Sony’s closed PlayStation ecosystem and a typical 30% commission on Store purchases created a “near monopoly” and led to “excessive and unfair prices.” It argued that digital game content would have been about 20% cheaper if rival stores had been allowed on the platform, and that the class was in line for about £162 each, a total of around £2 billion ($2.6 billion).
The tribunal rejected the idea that digital PlayStation games form a market of their own. It found that physical PlayStation games are likely to be significant substitutes for digital copies, and that Sony competes in a wider systems market with Xbox, Nintendo, and PC. Consumers, it said, can factor in the cost of games over a console’s lifetime when they choose a platform, and there was evidence they would switch consoles if game prices rose. The class representative had not advanced a case on that wider market, so the claim failed.
Even if that market definition had been accepted, the tribunal said the rest of the case would still have failed. It was not satisfied that Sony’s margin was excessive, particularly once the practice of selling consoles at relatively low margins and making the money back on game sales was taken into account. The claim that rival stores would have cut prices by about 20% was “not made out,” and the tribunal described the economic argument as based “almost entirely on theoretical assumptions, which did not hold good in important respects in the real world.”
Opening the platform to third-party stores, the tribunal added, would require “significant cost and effort” and would likely leave parts of the PlayStation Network with “materially reduced security” and potentially lower performance. It found the claim did not meet the legal test that would have required Sony to allow that kind of distribution on its system.
Physical games were still a meaningful part of PlayStation sales during the period covered by the claim. After the trial ended in May, the tribunal was told that Sony announced on July 1, 2026, that new PlayStation games will not be released on physical discs from January 2028. As we covered, PlayStation creator Ken Kutaragi later called the backlash to that plan a “mentality issue.” Sony has said games already released, or due out on disc before that date, are not affected, and that new titles will still be sold digitally on the PlayStation Store and at retail.
The claim is dismissed in its entirety, and no compensation has been awarded. The tribunal will hold a hearing in the week of Dec. 14, 2026, on costs and any application for permission to appeal. Neill, a co-founder of Consumer Voice, said she was disappointed and that the team is “carefully considering the judgment and our options, including whether to appeal this first-instance decision.”
The Game Business reports that Sony still faces similar class actions in Australia, the Netherlands, and Portugal, all at an earlier stage.
